Deprecated: Assigning the return value of new by reference is deprecated in /home/elleneme/public_html/wp-includes/cache.php on line 103

Deprecated: Assigning the return value of new by reference is deprecated in /home/elleneme/public_html/wp-includes/query.php on line 61

Deprecated: Assigning the return value of new by reference is deprecated in /home/elleneme/public_html/wp-includes/theme.php on line 1109
Ellen Emerson White » Blog Archive » Thoughts about some books

Archived Entry

Post Date : Oct 3, 2008 at 1807

Category : Boston Red Sox | Buffy the Vampire Slayer | Other Authors' Books | Photography

Do More : You can leave a response from your own site.

Thoughts about some books

October 3rd, 2008 by Ellen

Is it safe to talk about books these days?  I think it is, although I may be proven wrong.

I just finished Curtis Sittenfeld’s American Wife, and found it very unsettling, indeed.  Like Prep, I thought it was extremely well-observed, without being particularly engaging–or entertaining.  But, American Wife was a strange, and puzzling, choice, for a novelist to make.  The notion of a stranger publishing an extremely personal and speculative version of a person’s actual life is–I don’t know–unseemly. Rude, even.  It will certainly make the author rich, but I’m pretty confident that the author was already rich, so I’m not sure I see the point.  I would say that the entire project borders on stalking–except that I think it crossed the border, relocated to a new country entirely, settled down and began to grow crops.  (and if you find the Buffy reference in there, you’re good)

I suppose that Primary Colors was an unnecessary novel in a very similar way, but somehow, it seemed less–prurient.  Or, maybe just less scatological.  Then again, Joe Klein, for all his failings as a pundit, is simply a more compelling writer.  I suspect that Ms. Sittenfeld was aiming for Theodore Dreiser–which might have been a damned interesting creative choice, and a really good book–but, ended up with–well–Olivia Goldsmith, instead.  (It doesn’t help that the last third of the novel is a rushed blur, and clearly the result of trying to hit a demanding deadline schedule.)

American Wife is worth reading, and–sort of–ambitious, but after I finished it, I was left feeling as though I should go wash my hands.

I’m currently about halfway through Giles Blunt’s By The Time You Read This, which I’m enjoying.  A nice, solid book.  It won’t reinvent the wheel, but then again, it wasn’t designed to do so.

What else?  The Camera, by Ansel Adams.  Dense, demanding–and very informative.  Actually, I hope to read the entire series, but I’m starting with The Camera.  (Here’s a great article about photography, by the way, on an excellent site.)  Fletcher Knebel and Charles W. Bailey Il’s surprisingly not-as-dated-as-you-would-think Convention. A book about fishermen called Their Fathers’ WorkEverything the Instructors Never Told You About Mogul Skiing–because, even though such things are probably out of my reach, it can’t hurt to try to improve.  Red Sox Rule–for no other reason than because I feel like it.

And I was completely delighted to pick up an affordable secondhand copy of The New Professional Chef, which I had wanted for a really long time.

I haven’t read The War Within yet, but I assume I will, at some point.

And–it scarcely needs saying–but, go, Red Sox!

Posted in Boston Red Sox, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Other Authors' Books, Photography |

4 Responses

  1. Pam Says:

    I’m with you, I felt a little dirty after finishing American Wife. I liked that she made it clear that anyone related to the President is not the same as the President, but that could have easily been done without using a real person or twisting facts. And each of the 4 sections felt very different, making it hard to fit them together.

  2. EEW Says:

    Speculative fiction is odd, in any context–but, yeah, this book is just plain creepy, in a lot of ways.

  3. Katy Says:

    Thanks for your thougths on American Wife; I am intrigued and did put in a request for it from my local library, though I am also a little disturbed by the very concept of it.

    Although…Olivia Goldsmith? It could be worse, no? Perhaps I shouldn’t admit this, but as a writer of summer beach books, I think she was pretty good. Admittedly a few were god awful, but I seem to have fond memories of the one about the publishing industry.

  4. Ellen Says:

    Actually, I chose Olivia Goldsmith quite intentionally–_because_ she was a decent writer. I think Ms. Sittenfeld is also not without talent, which made her choice of subject that much more disturbing to me.

    Nothing like a good beach book–or a good thriller, I say.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.